• Select your country or region

Combined and Split-Grade Classes: Getting the Mix Right

A combined-grade class should be designed as a classroom, not filled as the last available space.

The Grade 1 and Grade 2 lists are almost finished when enrollment changes.

Grade configurations can change when the sizes of incoming cohorts shift. A school may need a combined-grade room one year and a different arrangement the next, regardless of its earlier preferences.

Class Solver insight

Combined-grade configurations should be planned, not treated as leftover places.

When the structure changes, a carefully balanced list can stop making sense overnight. The temptation is to preserve the straight-grade rooms and use the combined class to absorb whoever is left. That gives one teacher the consequences of everybody else’s decisions.

Three key points

  1. Design the combined-grade teaching model before selecting its students.
  2. Balance learning, support and friendships across every room, including the combined class.
  3. Avoid blanket claims that mixed-grade classes are automatically better or worse.

Start with the classroom, not the names

Before moving students, settle the essentials. Which curriculum will be taught to each grade? How will the teacher organize literacy and mathematics? What planning time, specialist support and grade-team collaboration will be available? What total enrollment and grade mix are workable?

Then build the class using the same care applied to every other room. Consider learning needs, friendships, access to services and the children’s ability to settle, rather than a shorthand list of the most compliant or independent students.

The way children are selected matters just as much as the planned teaching model. Do not assume that a combined-grade room should contain only independent students or become the place for whoever remains after the straight-grade classes are settled.

Review how every classroom will function. A decision that makes one split-grade room easier can move the pressure to another teacher. Check the learning mix, friendships and needed supports across all the classes involved.

What does the research actually say?

The research does not support a simple “split grades are better” or “split grades are worse” verdict. Veenman’s 1995 review found no consistent achievement disadvantage, but Mason and Burns (1996) argued that selection of pupils and teaching conditions complicated the comparison. That methodological debate matters: schools do not necessarily place students into combined classes at random. [1–2]

Newer evidence is varied. A 2023 Scottish study found short-lived literacy and numeracy gains for children starting school alongside older pupils, with no detected disadvantage for those older classmates. A 2023 Italian study found a short-term achievement benefit in Grade 2, but less favourable results for children spending multiple years in multigrade classes; teacher experience appeared to matter. By contrast, a US observational analysis of 11,000 kindergarteners, including only around 200 in combined pre-K/kindergarten classrooms, found smaller literacy and math gains among children in those mixed-age classrooms than among their kindergarten-only peers. These studies examine different ages, countries and classroom models and should not be combined into a single average. [3–5]

Changing the grade configuration changes the relationships too

Multi-age classrooms may raise additional relationship and family considerations: siblings could end up together, or students could gain new friendships while losing familiar peers. These possibilities need an appropriate check rather than an automatic rule.

Imagine a school adjusting its class-size arrangements and opening an additional single-grade classroom. Students may need to be reassigned from several existing rooms, affecting both grade balance and important peer relationships.

Changing the number or grade mix of classes requires revisiting connected placement decisions.

Changing the grade configuration is a whole-grade decision, not a reason to label particular children as naturally suitable or unsuitable for combined-grade learning. Recheck student relationships, grade proportions, support needs and staffing across both combined- and single-grade classrooms. Software can help compare scenarios, but the school must confirm that its local class structure is represented correctly.

Try This

Design the combined-grade classroom first

Write a brief plan for curriculum, staffing, grade mix, learning support and planning time. Then build every class together and check the combined room for both instructional feasibility and individual relationships.

A combined-grade room is not a leftover class. It needs its own teaching plan, the right support and as much care in placement as any single-grade room.

Research Sources

[1] Veenman, S. (1995). Cognitive and noncognitive effects of multigrade and multi-age classes: A best-evidence synthesis. Review of Educational Research, 65(4), 319–381. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543065004319.
[2] Mason, D. A., & Burns, R. B. (1996). “Simply no worse and simply no better” may simply be wrong: A critique of Veenman’s conclusion about multigrade classes. Review of Educational Research, 66(3), 307–322. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543066003307.
[3] Borbely, D., et al. (2023). Early years multi-grade classes and pupil attainment. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 85(6), 1295–1319. https://doi.org/10.1111/obes.12561.
[4] Barbetta, G. P., et al. (2023). Good or bad? Understanding the effects over time of multigrading on child achievement. Economics of Education Review, 96, 102442. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econedurev.2023.102442.
[5] Ansari, A. (2017). Multi-grade kindergarten classrooms and children’s academic achievement, executive function, and socio-emotional development. Infant and Child Development, 26(6), e2036. https://doi.org/10.1002/icd.2036.
These studies examine different ages, systems and classroom models. None identifies the ideal class composition for a particular school.

Back To Top