• Select your country or region

Should Schools Ask About Friendships When Building Classes?

Before deciding where friends should be placed, schools face a more basic choice: should they collect friendship nominations, and how would they use them?

Consider a fictional draft in which several children have no recorded positive peer connections in their proposed classrooms. The gap would not necessarily appear in academic or behavior information. It becomes visible only if staff collect and check friendship input.

Class Solver’s interviews reveal variation in practice: some schools collect student friendship nominations systematically, while others do not collect them at all. That variation makes the question worth asking: what might a school gain from collecting friendship information, and what extra work and professional judgment would the process require?

Three key points

  1. Friendship input is optional, but it can reveal relationships that academic or behavior data will not show.
  2. Ask consistently and interpret carefully: a missing nomination does not prove a child is isolated.
  3. Use the information to guide thoughtful placements and a welcoming start, not to promise every friendship.

What friendship questions can add

A school that has never asked about friendships does not need a complex survey. A modest starting point is to invite children, in an age-appropriate way, to name a few classmates they feel comfortable learning or spending time with. Teachers can also note positive peer connections they have actually observed. This may help staff notice a child who has only one important connection, a child whose nominated peers are all in other classes, or a peer group that tends to stay together every year. None is automatically a problem; each adds useful context.

For schools that collect friendship nominations, completeness matters. A child may appear to have no connections simply because relevant friendship information was never entered. Before drawing a conclusion about social isolation, check the source of the blank record.

Class Solver insight

A missing friendship nomination is a data gap until someone checks it.

The blank record may be a data gap, not evidence of social isolation. A nomination can be one-way or mutual; a student may be named by others without naming them back. Patterns of non-nomination can prompt helpful questions, but they cannot tell a school how a child feels or predict what friendships will develop.

Benefits depend on how schools respond

The most useful discovery may be that a child needs a familiar peer to help them settle, or that a seemingly close friendship is no longer supportive in class. Such information should prompt staff to check observations, speak with the child when appropriate, and decide whether the class or the transition plan needs attention.

The benefit is not that a diagram makes the decision. It is that considered relationship information may reveal a question the team would otherwise miss.

Friendship information earns its place when it leads to better questions and support.

Where schools collect these nominations, support teams can check whether children with few recorded connections need a more intentional start. Other schools may decide the effort of gathering friendship information is not justified for their setting. Neither choice should be mistaken for an exact measure of social wellbeing.

The limits of the information

Friendship requests can be out of date, one-sided or shaped by the way a question is asked. Children may have strong relationships outside their grade or make new friends quickly. And preserving every nominated pair can conflict with important learning and support needs. If a school collects nominations, explain that they are one input, not a promise. Check that every student had the same opportunity to respond and avoid turning a visual label into a judgment about a child.

Whatever the initial placement, the first weeks still matter. Receiving teachers can introduce children thoughtfully, use varied learning partners and notice who seems left out. In a randomized seating study in Hungary, Rohrer, Keller and Elwert (2021) found that students seated together were more likely to form mutual friendships. This was a seating experiment, not a study of annual class lists; it shows how proximity can create opportunities for connection. Rohrer, Keller & Elwert (2021), PLOS ONE, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0255097.

Try This

The friendship-information test

If your school does not record friendship input, ask whether a simple, optional nomination would help reveal overlooked connections. If you do collect it, ask: Was every child given an equal chance to respond? Are we treating nominations as clues rather than facts? What will teachers do with the information before and after placement?

A spreadsheet, a teacher conversation or a sociogram can help make connections visible. The important decision comes earlier: whether your school wants to collect this information, what it hopes to learn, and how it will use it responsibly. The opportunity is not to draw a better diagram; it is to see something useful about the children that might otherwise go unnoticed.

Related reading

Back To Top